Saxton Hell Back to SaxtonHell.com

Remove voting

  1. Wizzy

    Remove voting

    #5671
    I am suggesting that nominating and voting for maps is completely removed from deathrun. We literally had an argument over what maps are good, what maps are bad, what maps we can play on, which ones we can't play on. It broke down into a mud flinging contest and a nomination war. Remove the nominating and voting and you stop the stupidity and people bitching about maps. It also prevents the same 7 maps from being played over and over again, and gives a challenge to players who have never played on certain maps, or never vote for them because they are too hard. The whole purpose of deathrun is for the player to survive as long as possible and make it to the end to win, and the hale's job is to stop them. When people argue over maps it kinda removes from that idea, I like to have variety, it helps me learn new techniques and increases my skill level as a player, not spamming the same 7 maps where you just rush to the end as fast as possible. Just my two cents.
  2. Punishment_Fatal STEAM_0:1:43817148

    Re: Remove voting

    #5672
    Wizzy wrote View original post
    I am suggesting that nominating and voting for maps is completely removed from deathrun. We literally had an argument over what maps are good, what maps are bad, what maps we can play on, which ones we can't play on. It broke down into a mud flinging contest and a nomination war. Remove the nominating and voting and you stop the stupidity and people bitching about maps. It also prevents the same 7 maps from being played over and over again, and gives a challenge to players who have never played on certain maps, or never vote for them because they are too hard. The whole purpose of deathrun is for the player to survive as long as possible and make it to the end to win, and the hale's job is to stop them. When people argue over maps it kinda removes from that idea, I like to have variety, it helps me learn new techniques and increases my skill level as a player, not spamming the same 7 maps where you just rush to the end as fast as possible. Just my two cents.

    Maybe change it to donators nominate only? If not, then I guess they can remove it.
  3. √oiDeD STEAM_0:0:4491990

    Re: Remove voting

    #5675
    I don't really think that removing map voting entirely is the way to solve that issue. Neither would making it be only accessible to donators. If you want to see variety, nominate maps that are underplayed.
  4. Punishment_Fatal STEAM_0:1:43817148

    Re: Remove voting

    #5680
    VoiDeD wrote View original post
    I don't really think that removing map voting entirely is the way to solve that issue. Neither would making it be only accessible to donators. If you want to see variety, nominate maps that are underplayed.

    The only problem I see with this is what happens on the server actively. Since barely anyone knows the maps that aren't nominated because a lot of new people come onto the server, the nominations usually slide over the played maps. With this, even if another map that isn't played gets nominated, the newer people will pick what map they know/what the rest of the crowd is wanting them to go to.
  5. jay STEAM_0:0:38563092

    Re: Remove voting

    #5685
    The removal of map-nomination won't lower the amount of stupid mud-slinging at all. It's just the nature of the server.
  6. Wizzy

    Re: Remove voting

    #5688
    Some people literally nominate a map as soon as a new map loads up, I am only 1 person, and I don't load up the fastest, so I often get stuck nominating a map last. It's a whole bunch of nonsense when people get into nomination wars over the same 7 maps and start whining and fighting because their map did not get the first nomination, and the crying over the "1 spam". If you set the maps to random it will keep us guessing, and if it cycles through them all before cycling through again it keeps us guessing, and we get to play on all the maps.
  7. Mikku44 STEAM_0:1:49049906

    Re: Remove voting

    #5696
    Voided have you ever heard of the legendary "1 spam"? If i nominate the worst map in deathrun and its in the 1 vote slot everyone will vote for it cry for 30min why we are on this shitty map and then i can nominate another map first then the cycle continues
  8. √oiDeD STEAM_0:0:4491990

    Re: Remove voting

    #5697
    Removing map voting doesn't solve 1 spam.

    Reordering how the maps display in the list or require other keys to be pressed solves 1 spam.
  9. Wizzy

    Re: Remove voting

    #5698
    Okay, how about this, we remove the nominating sequence, and have the server pick a map at random, and we vote on whether or not we play on it, or if we want to skip it, if we skip, it will just choose another random map and make it the map we play on. I honestly don't care what maps we do play on, I just like having some variety and a challenge, and as I have said, arguing over maps and making a nomination war seems pretty silly.
  10. √oiDeD STEAM_0:0:4491990

    Re: Remove voting

    #5702
    I still don't believe that removing nominations is the right way to go. While it may make some group of players happy, others will potentially be upset. For now I'm not going to be making any changes, as nominations and map voting are the mainstay and de facto method of choosing maps on many servers, and it's expected to be in place by many players.

    However, I will look into seeing if the map vote process can be modified.

    Here are some ideas I have in mind (these are only prospective ideas, which may or may not be implemented at some point):

    • It would be ideal to move the voting keys down a few numbers so that instead of 1 through 6, players must hit 4 through 9.
    • Randomize the order of maps displayed to every player. So one player's 1 map will differ from another player's 1 map. This has the possibility of confusing many players who expect everyone to see the same order, though.
    • Make use of F1, F2, F3, etc. There are significant downsides to this, however, as Valve's voting system has a reduced number of choices so the voting set will be reduced to less maps,and "extend map" would become unavailable.
  11. Wizzy

    Re: Remove voting

    #5703
    I like the second idea, it prevents 1 spamming, it forces players to think about their decisions, and it gives underplayed maps a chance to be voted up instead of being shadowed from the constant nominating - 1 spam chain.
  15. Wizzy

    Re: Remove voting

    #5719
    Basically jay it means you vote doesnt count towards a map, essentially you are "wasting" it.

Archive Notice

The Saxton Hell community forums have been retried. This website is available as a read-only archive. Join us on Discord for the latest discussions!

Join the Saxton Hell Discord server